New York remains a global hub for innovation, culture, and commerce, and the same can be said of its digital marketing scene. In this ultra-competitive city, your brand’s online visibility is equally crucial as its physical presence in Times Square billboards or SoHo’s retail frontlines. Whether you’re a startup looking to expand, a mid-sized company looking to dominate social, or a global brand launching a new campaign, this list of the best social media marketing agencies in New York (2025) will help you find the right partner. From influencer marketing to viral short-form content, these agencies have a proven track record of developing brands and driving revenue in a city that never sleeps.
15 Best Social Media Marketing Agencies In New York (2025)
1. DMi Digital Marketing Agency
Location: London and Abuja with remote teams in the US
Campaign Volume: 500+ high-converting campaigns and ad spend managed in the past year.
Website: DMi Agency
DMi Digital Marketing Agency, also known as DMi Agency, is an emerging force in global marketing, combining originality with global marketing standards that fits businesses in New York City. We’ve handled projects across the US, UK, KSA, Nigeria and more—executing creative campaigns for NYC brands like Digital Homes and California-based financial consulting firm, RADD LLC. Our work often results in boosted engagement, stronger brand visibility, and measurable increases in client revenue and leads, proving that their strategies go beyond surface-level success. If you’re looking for an agency that understands strategic marketing, branding, and ROI, DMi Agency is your partner.
2. Socialfly
Locations: Based in NYC with partners in Miami and Los Angeles.
Campaign Volume: 1,000+ influencer-first campaigns in the past year.
Website: Socialfly
Socialfly is a dynamic, women-led agency transforming the way brands engage with their audiences. Their creative team had helped beauty and lifestyle brands grow rapidly, including one case where a client gained tens of thousands of new followers and significantly boosted engagement in under nine months. Recognized by media outlets such as Forbes, Inc., and Entrepreneur, Socialfly has become a preferred partner for brands looking to incorporate influencers and storytelling into their TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube strategies. Their NYC clients feature names like Conair, Discovery+, and Bare Minerals.
3. The Sasha Group (by VaynerX)
Locations: Headquartered in NYC, with additional presence in Chattanooga.
Campaign Volume: 800+ brand-forward campaigns annually.
Website: The Sasha Group
A branch of VaynerX owned by serial entrepreneur Gary Vaynerchuk (Gary Vee), The Sasha Group brings big agency thinking to growing brands. They’ve helped legacy brands adapt to younger audiences with modern content. They are regularly featured in AdAge and Forbes, making them a go-to agency for NYC firms in search of performance-focused storytelling.
4. Firebelly Marketing
Location: HQ in Indianapolis with a major client base in New York.
Campaign Volume: 300+ influencer and lifestyle campaigns annually.
Website: Firebelly
Firebelly specializes in helping food and lifestyle brands grow authentically. Their campaigns for brands like KIND Snacks and Sony Music have earned media attention for driving results through organic engagement. They’ve been featured in Clutch and The New York Times.
5. Iron Roots
Location: Austin HQ with teams in NYC and San Francisco.
Campaign Volume: 600+ UGC and short-form video campaigns.
Website: Ironroots
Iron Roots is a creative content studio focused on performance-driven UGC. Their TikTok activations have helped brands gain visibility, with some videos hitting over 1 million views in a single month. They’ve been recognized by outlets like Social Media Examiner and Digiday. Their work in NYC features growth campaigns for Rent the Runway and fashion startups aimed at Gen Zs.
6. OpenMoves
Location: HQ Huntington, NY
Campaign Volume: 700+ precision-targeted social campaigns.
Website: OpenMoves
OpenMoves is a performance marketing agency focused on delivering ROI through precision targeting and analytics. A recent campaign for a SaaS client based in NYC reportedly doubled return on ad spend (ROAS) within 90 days. Having received accolades from HubSpot and MarketingProfs, they rank among the leading agencies for data-centric strategies on platforms like Facebook, LinkedIn, and Google Ads.
8. Crafted NYC
Location: SoHo, NYC with teams in Toronto and London.
Campaign Volume: 300+ luxury and lifestyle campaigns.
Website: CraftedNYC
Crafted NYC specializes in creating digital experiences that resonate emotionally, describing itself as ‘a brand-first creative agency’. With multinationals like Saks Fifth Avenue and Sotheby’s, CraftedNYC’s award-winning design work has appeared in Fast Company and Communication Arts.
9. NoGood
Locations: Based in NYC with teams across Europe and South America.
Campaign Volume: 500+ full-funnel performance campaigns.
Website: NoGood
NoGood fuses growth marketing with engaging viral creativity. A skincare brand they managed saw a 300% increase. Named a top agency by Adweek and The Drum, NoGood collaborates across the SaaS, lifestyle, and eCommerce fields.
10. Voy Media
Locations: NYC with remote teams in Miami and Austin.
Campaign Volume: 700+ direct-response ad campaigns.
Website: VoyMedia
Voy Media employs a bold strategy for scaling by utilizing ad creatives that drive conversions. One of their campaigns enabled a beverage brand to achieve $100K in monthly subscriptions via Meta and TikTok Ads. Acknowledged by Forbes and Adweek, Voy Media has fueled growth for notable brands like Lacoste, Paw.com, and other major eCommerce players in NYC.
11. The Charles Group
Locations: NYC HQ with studios in London and Chicago.
Campaign Volume: 350+ luxury-driven campaigns.
Website: TheCharles
Founded by sibling Aaron Edwards and Samantha Edwards in 2011, The Charles is known for its upscale, design-oriented content. Their strategy for a legacy hotel group increased engagement by 270% and their client roster includes a two centuries-old jewelry brand, Cartier and and household name, BMW NYC. Featured in Vogue Business and Surface Magazine, The Charles Group is a leading choice for luxury and fashion brands.
12. Power Digital
Locations: San Diego HQ with major operations in NYC.
Campaign Volume: 1,200+ campaigns across paid and organic channels.
Website: PowerDigital
Power Digital assisted a startup in expanding its customer base from 10K to 300K through cohesive social video campaigns. They are an excellent match for startups and scaleups in NYC. Recognized by Inc. and Mashable, Power Digital merges compelling storytelling with media buying that emphasizes conversions.
13. Taktical Digital
Locations: HQ in NYC with clients in over 20 countries.
Campaign Volume: 800+ campaigns across Meta, LinkedIn & TikTok.
Website: Taktical
Taktical’s team, dedicated to digital growth, propelled a sneaker brand from $25K to $220K in monthly revenue. They excel in eCommerce scaling and retargeting. Highlighted in HuffPost and HubSpot, they are a reliable agency for fashion, retail, and B2C businesses.
14. AMP Agency
Locations: Boston HQ with full-service NYC office.
Campaign Volume: 600+ Pinterest and IG-focused campaigns.
Website: Amp
AMP Agency uses eye-catching creative to drive sales. They helped a home retailer achieve 3x ROI using pin-to-purchase campaigns. Among their NYC clientele are Loews Hotels and H&M. Showcased in AdExchanger and eMarketer, they excel in producing attention-grabbing visuals.
15. Flightpath
Locations: Based in New York City.
Campaign Volume: 450+ integrated social campaigns in 2024.
Website: Flightpath
Flightpath blends creativity and strategy to drive brand growth. A recent campaign helped a health-tech startup increase social shares by 250% and organic traffic by over 400%. Clients include Scholastic, Goya Foods, and NYC nonprofits.
Red Flags to Look Out for When Hiring a Social Media Marketing Agency in New York
Choosing the wrong marketing agency to manage your digital presence not only costs you money and time, it stalls your growth and can even damage your brand reputation. Here are some red flags to watch out for when choosing a social media marketing agency:
1. No case studies or clients’ results
If an agency cannot show you real results backed with proof or verified success stories, that’s a major red flag. All reputable agencies proudly showcase their past campaigns even if the client names are anonymous.
2. Overpromising without a strategy
Beware of agencies that guarantee viral posts, 10k followers within a week or overnight sales because social media growth takes time, strategy, and consistent execution to bring results and theirs no shortcut to this
3. Vague or no reporting
You should always have access to performance data. If an agency cannot provide clear, regular reports with metrics like engagement, reach and ROI, walk away.
4. One-size-fits-all package
If an agency doesn’t take the time to understand your business goals, audience or industry first before offering or suggesting services to you. They may not be the partner you’re looking for because not all businesses are the same.
5. Too focused on vanity metric
Likes and follows are great, but do they lead to your desired conversion rate — customers spending on your product or service like never before? A good agency focuses on metrics that drive growth such as leads, clicks, and…sales.
FAQs on Best Social Media Marketing Agencies in New York
1. What does a social media marketing agency do?
A social media marketing agency helps businesses grow their online presence through strategic content creation, paid advertising, community management, influencer collaborations, and performance tracking on platforms like Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, LinkedIn, and YouTube.
2. How much does it cost to hire a social media agency in New York?
The cost varies based on your goals, platform focus, and scope of work.
3. What should I look for in a top NYC social media agency?
Look for agencies with:
- Proven case studies and client success stories
- Experience in your industry
- Transparent pricing and reporting
- Strong communication and onboarding process
- Services tailored to your business goals
4. Is it better to work with a local NYC agency or a remote team?
A local agency offers in-person meetings, cultural familiarity, and faster collaboration. However, remote agencies may offer more flexible pricing and a global perspective. The best choice depends on your brand’s needs and working style.
5. Can a social media agency help small businesses or startups?
Absolutely. Many NYC social media agencies offer scalable solutions for small businesses—from brand awareness to lead generation and eCommerce growth. Look for agencies that work with startups or offer customized, budget-friendly plans.
7. How long before I see results from a social media campaign?
You can expect early signs of growth (engagement, reach) within the first 30–60 days. Tangible business results like leads or sales may take 3 to 6 months, depending on your offer, industry, and consistency.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right social media agency is more than selecting a vendor, it’s about forming a partnership with a team that understands your vision, speaks your brand’s language, and is driven by measurable outcomes. The 15 agencies we spotlighted bring a diverse mix of strengths, from performance marketing to luxury storytelling, so aligning with a team that reflects your priorities whether it’s virality, ROI, or creative excellence is key.
At DMi Agency, we believe in data-driven storytelling, full-funnel activation, and ROI-first strategies. Our work is not just about chasing trends, it’s about building systems that scale, communities that convert, and brands that stand the test of time. We don’t just deliver reports; we drive real business breakthroughs.
If you’re searching for a strategic partner to elevate your social presence in 2025, let’s talk. Together, we can turn insights into impact, transform visibility into revenue, and build campaigns that matter. Ready to start the conversation?
Contact DMi Agency today for a free strategy session and let’s chart a winning path forward because your brand’s next chapter deserves nothing less,
